• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

North Star Mutual Insurance Company

  • Insurance
    • Farm
    • Home
    • Auto
    • Commercial
    • Umbrella
  • Find an Agent
  • Claims
    • Claims Service
    • Report a Claim
    • Claims FAQ
  • Careers
    • Careers
    • Internships
  • About
    • About Us
    • Blog / News
    • FAQs
    • Contact Us
  • Make a Payment
Smiling family of four stands together outside a house surrounded by green plants and trees.

Keeping You on Course

When the unexpected happens, we’ll be here to help you get back on track.

Black location pin icon centered on a pale background.

Find an Agent

Credit card icon with two overlapping circles on the right and horizontal lines on the left side.

Make a Payment

Shield icon featuring a check mark in the center, representing security or protection.

Claims Service

About Us

Since the 1920s, North Star Mutual has provided trusted property and casualty insurance for families, farmers, and business owners. From home and auto insurance to farm and commercial insurance, our policies are built keep you moving forward when life doesn’t go as planned.

We work exclusively through local independent insurance agents who know your community and are there when you need them. Strong local relationships and dependable service is central to who we are.

Learn More About Us
AM Best logo and A+ Superior rating in white text shown on a light gray background.

A+ Financial Strength

Rated ‘A+ Superior’ by
A.M. Best since 2005.

Five outlined figures stand beside a basic house icon on a light, plain background.

400k+ Policyholders

Serving over 400,000
policyholders in 8 states.

Hand outline holding a check featuring a dollar sign and a checkmark.

42k+ Claims

North Star paid over
42,000 Claims in 2025.

Insurance Products

North Star Mutual offers a wide range of insurance policies and coverage options to meet your unique needs.

Two cars in the driveway of a large brick and tan suburban house, trees visible behind the home.

Personal Insurance

Home and auto insurance help protect the things you rely on every day. Our personal insurance policies are designed to safeguard your home, vehicles, and personal property while providing confidence and peace of mind for the future.

Explore Personal Policies
Red tractor parked by a building, with a cornfield and clear sky in the background.

Farm Insurance

Our farm insurance policies are built to protect your operation, buildings, equipment, and livestock, with dependable support from people who understand rural properties and the challenges that come with them.

Explore Farm
Coverage
Sunny small-town street lined with historic brick buildings, leafy trees, and people strolling along the sidewalk.

Commercial Insurance

Running a business comes with risk, and unexpected setbacks can impact more than just your bottom line. Our commercial insurance options help protect your business, employees, and property so you can focus on serving your customers.

Explore Commercial Coverage

Find a Local Agent

Finding the right insurance coverage starts with a trusted local independent agent. They can help you understand coverage options, find policies that fit your needs and budget, and provide ongoing support with policy changes and claims. 

Locate an Agent

FAQs

What is the purpose of insurance? Do I need it?

Insurance is a trusted financial tool that protects people and businesses from risk and plays a vital role in sustaining the broader economy. It is meant to help you return to your pre-loss financial state after a sudden, accidental and unexpected loss. Damage or wear to property that occurs gradually over time through normal use, aging, or lack of maintenance is the responsibility of the property owner. These are things people know will happen and can plan on saving money to replace or fix over time. 

What is included in my policy’s coverage? Where do I find it?

Your policy outlines the coverages, limits, deductibles, exclusions, and endorsements that apply to your insurance. You can find this information in your policy documents or declarations (“dec”) page. Copies of your dec page are typically sent to you in the mail and can also be accessed through the North Star Mutual Mobile App. Your agent is a great resource to help review your coverages and answer questions.

How do I make changes to my policy or update my personal information?

To make changes to your policy, such as adding or removing coverage, updating vehicles or drivers, or changing your contact information, contact your independent insurance agent. They can guide you through the process and help ensure your policy stays up to date.

What is a deductible and how does it affect my premiums? Should I choose a higher or lower deductible?

A deductible is the portion of a covered loss you are responsible for paying before insurance coverage applies. A higher deductible typically lowers your premium but means paying more out of pocket if a claim occurs. A lower deductible generally results in higher premiums but lower out-of-pocket costs at claim time. Your choice should reflect your financial situation and comfort level with risk.

How can I save money on my insurance premiums? What discounts are available?

There are many ways to potentially lower your premiums, including bundling policies, choosing higher deductibles, maintaining a good claims history, improving property safety features, and qualifying for available discounts. Your agent can help identify savings opportunities that may apply to you.

Blog

A family relaxes outside, wrapped in blankets and enjoying hot drinks together.

“A+ Superior” Rating Affirmed by A.M. Best

North Star’s AM Best rating of A+ (Superior) has been reaffirmed! We are proud to hold this status with AM Best, the nation’s most widely…

Continue Reading “A+ Superior” Rating Affirmed by A.M. Best

Nine people stand in a row holding a check beneath a North Star Mutual Insurance Company sign.

North Star Mutual Boosts Cottonwood Community Foundation with FHLB Des Moines

North Star Mutual partners with Federal Home Loan Bank of Des Moines to award $100,000 to the Cottonwood Area Community Foundation through Member Impact Fund.…

Continue Reading North Star Mutual Boosts Cottonwood Community Foundation with FHLB Des Moines

Greg Boerboom

Boerboom Appointed to North Star Mutual Board of Directors

Greg Boerboom of Marshall, MN, was appointed to North Star Mutual Insurance Company’s Board of Directors in January of 2024. Boerboom, along with his wife,…

Continue Reading Boerboom Appointed to North Star Mutual Board of Directors

“We had a lot of claims in June with multiple carriers. North Star is way quicker with contact. Our insureds felt heard and were very impressed with service.”
– Brittney L., Bravera Insurance

Blue quotation mark icon set against a plain white background.

Footer

North Star Mutual Insurance Company

North Star Mutual Insurance Company
269 Barstad Road South, PO Box 48
Cottonwood, MN 56229
Call: 800-622-5230

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

About Us

Partnerships
Blog
Contact Us

Insurance

Farm
Home
Auto
Business/Commercial
Umbrella

Find Agent

Make Payment

Claims Service

Report Claim
Claims FAQ

Careers

Internships

Legal Notices

Minnesota
Iowa
Nebraska
North Dakota
Oklahoma
South Dakota
Wisconsin

Agent Login

Copyright © 2026 North Star Mutual Insurance Co. All rights reserved. View data Privacy Policy. Developed by Vivid Image.